Question #13
Reading: Reading 42.5 Standards of Professional Conduct Guidance for Standards V
PDF File: Reading 42.5 Standards of Professional Conduct Guidance for Standards V.pdf
Page: 9
Status: Unattempted
Correct Answer: A
Part of Context Group: Q13-15
First in Group
Shared Context
Question
With regard to his coverage of HighLife stock, Singh:
Answer Choices:
A. did not violate the Standards for reasonable basis or research reports
B. violated the research reports Standard because he failed to differentiate between facts and opinions
C. violated the reasonable basis Standard by downgrading a stock because it missed one quarterly earnings estimate
Explanation
Singh reported a series of facts that led him to draw a conclusion, and identified the
conclusion as his own. No nonpublic information was used in the HighLife analysis. While
Singh did say that missing an earnings target would spur a downgrade, he made it clear
that he had broader concerns about the firm's market share. Missing an earnings target
would simply be confirmation of his concerns, and thus be the catalyst to his change of
opinion.